Sutcliffe “felt righteous” as he killed for God

The Guardian, 14 May 1981

The forensic psychiatrist to whom Peter Sutcliffe first mentioned his divine mission to kill prostitutes yesterday defended his view that Mr Sutcliffe is a paranoid schizophrenic.

On the eighth day of the Old Bailey trial, Dr Hugo Milne listed 19 symptoms or signs of the illness. The crucial symptom was a “primary schizophrenic experience” such as the voice which spoke to Mr Sutcliffe as he dug a grave in Bingley cemetery. But other symptoms were necessary to confirm the illness. “This man has got more than sufficient to make a diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia,” added Dr Milne.

There were his preoccupation with prostitutes, his over-controlled behaviour, his illogical thinking, his lack of insight into the reasons for his actions, his feeling that his mind was being controlled, his distortions of thought and of perception.

His reaction to the news that his then girlfriend, Sonia, was seeing another man was of some significance. He had become very distressed and suspicious and had temporarily suffered from the delusion that Sonia was a prostitute.

When he was cheated of £10 by a prostitute soon afterwards, he had felt a hatred for her and for all prostitutes. Dr Milne said: “There is this progression from what initially might have been the feeling of anger to hatred and then extending that to physical violence and then from one prostitute to any prostitute.”

Dr Milne said he had been particularly impressed by Sutcliffe’s language and demeanour when he described how the voice first spoke to him in the graveyard. “It was as if he was describing something that at the time was mystical, magical, something that he hadn’t experienced before. Bearing that in mind, his glimpses of extravagant emotion in the sense of being open and looking content and happy were quite striking.

“He was elated and excited and there was overt emotion. But in the majority of interviews he was emotionally flat and controlled, and there was no warmth or emotion.”

Dr Milne said that it was not surprising that Sutcliffe’s description of the words on the gravestone did not fit the facts. “He Is hearing a voice. He must try to explain it to himself. For a man hearing a voice for the first time this must be a rather shattering experience so he sees the words and implies a meaning which is there for him and for no one else.”

It was not surprising that Mr Sutcliffe had failed to act on his mission between 1969 and 1975. “Once a person is schizophrenic, it doesn’t mean that they behave progressively as a schizophrenic throughout the period. There may be fluctuations. The individual who has these desires – to inflict harm – may still be so much in contact with reality that he may make very conscious efforts to resist them.”

The failure of the police inquiry, the appearance of the hoax letters and tape, had only served to encourage him and to increase his feeling of grandeur. Sutcliffe had told one police officer that he felt driven by the Devil.

Wasn’t this a contradiction? Mr Chadwin asked. Dr Milne said: “If an experience is mystical and magical it can either be God or the Devil, good or bad.” Mr Sutcliffe had found it hard to decide whether it was God or the Devil who was speaking to him.

Dr Milne said that Sutcliffe’s calm state of mind when he was making his admission to the police showed abnormal control. Normal people would show anxiety under cross-examination, but Sutcliffe “behaved with an abnormal degree of calmness, detachment and quiet.”

When he later interviewed Sutcliffe after the trial began, he was “quiet, pleased to be seen, affable, pleasant and extremely controlled.”

Dr Milne was asked what effect he thought the motorcycle accident had had on Sutcliffe. Dr Milne replied: “I attach no clinical significance as far as causation of illness, but it’s likely that a man mentally ill would try and time the onset of illness to an occurrence which was out of the usual.”

He said that it was not inconsistent with schizophrenia that Sutcliffe should have sharpened a screwdriver in an act of deliberation and premeditation.

Dr Milne then went through the notes he made during 11 interviews with Sutcliffe between January 14 and April 9 this year.

After the first interview, he said he had got nowhere near diagnosing Sutcliffe as suffering from mental illness. After the second he had been “slightly more suspicious that the man was not as mentally well as he might be.”

The third interview, on February 5, was important since it was the first time that Sutcliffe had used the word “mission.” He said he deliberately avoided reacting to this in case it was an attempt to persuade him that Sutcliffe was mentally ill.

Sutcliffe had gone on to describe his hallucinations: “I get flashes of light, a complete brilliant flash which obliterates everything?” Dr Milne said that this was typical of a schizophrenic’s description of hallucinations. At the end of this interview he began to think that Sutcliffe was a paranoid schizophrenic “but because he was charged with such violent offences, I could not come to that conclusion as readily as I would if it was someone else.”

At the fourth Interview, on February 12, Sutcliffe had told him: “I got to the stage I might have gone into a town where people were shopping and attacked any woman.”

Later he told Dr Milne: “I felt detached front the offences. I could talk about it with people at work. I could have conversations and talk about it like anybody else could.”

Sutcliffe had said of his interviews with the police in the years before he was arrested: “I could talk so calmly without being distressed. They were satisfied that it was not me.”

He said he had not been frightened. “Some of the time I had a conflict when I was doing these deeds. I felt I was doing the right thing and at other times it was quite the opposite – in a turmoil.”

Asked what he meant by doing “the right thing”, Sutcliffe had replied: “Like I was living in someone else’s shoes when I was doing it. Doing everyone a service. I felt righteous, doing everyone a favour.”

At the seventh interview, on March 5, Sutcliffe had told of his honeymoon in Paris in 1974 when he thought a man had tried to drag Sonia away, thinking she was a prostitute.

Later, after describing one killing in Manchester, Sutcliffe had commented: “Who am I to deserve honour? A very unpleasant duty. Other people have been ordained in the past to do God’s duty. You can’t question it A very difficult position to be in.”

Asked during the eighth interview why he felt he had been deserted, Sutcliffe re-plied: “I may deserve a rest. For perhaps he’s chosen someone else, but I think I have heard God since I have been here” (Armley Gaol).

Asked whether Sutcliffe could have simulated his symptoms, Dr Milne replied: “I had been looking for this all the time and I cannot accept that in the sequence his symptoms were made known to me that they could have been simulated.”

Mr Chadwin then asked him: “You have said that at intervals he has indicated that if he were at liberty he would be likely to kill again. Do you regard him as dangerous?”

Dr Milne said: “Not dangerous. Extremely dangerous.”

The trial continues today.