Peter Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper, denied at the Old Bailey yesterday that he was mad or that he had ever planned to pretend to be mad.
He told his counsel, Mr James Chadwin QC, that he had believed an adviser who had told him that “the prosecution and defence had agreed to accept the plea of diminished responsibility.”
Mr Sutcliffe has pleaded not guilty to murdering 13 women but guilty to their manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.
He said while giving evidence on the seventh day of his trial that when his wife, Sonia, visited him in prison, he had reluctantly told her that it was pointless wasting her life waiting for him because he would be serving 30 years or more.
“I could see what effect I was having on her and I just couldn’t go through with it – pretending I didn’t care and turning her away,” he said.
“It was my means of trying to cheer her up, that I said something to the effect of ‘Not to worry, they’d probably think I was mad and I would spend 10 years in a loony bin.’ This had the effect of cheering her up. I wiped the tears from her face and licked them.”
Mr Chadwin asked: “Did you then, or at any time, have it in mind to pretend to be mad.”
Mr Sutcliffe: “No.”
Mr Chadwin: “Do you think you are mad?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “No.”
Mr Chadwin: “Do you think there is anything wrong with you mentally?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “Nothing serious at all, no.”
Mr Chadwin: “Do you think you will spend less time in custody if people think there is something wrong with you?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “No. There would be something wrong with me mentally if I thought that.”
Earlier in his evidence, he told of the moment he was arrested. He said that by the time the police arrived he felt no animosity towards his companion, Miss Olivia Reivers, a prostitute.
He was asked why he had dropped the weapons he was carrying against a nearby wall, and replied: “Because they were obvious pointers to what my intentions were.”
He had confessed to being the Ripper because “I had just been given the signal through the police that it was time to tell them.” The message had come from God.
He agreed he had told the police that he was glad it was all over “because I had been through terrible suffering all the time.”
Mr Chadwin asked: “In what way did you suffer?”
Mr Sutcliffe replied: “Having to go through with the mission against my will.”
Sir Michael Havers QC, prosecuting, began his cross-examination by asking Mr Sutcliffe about the night of his arrest. Mr Sutcliffe agreed that he had hidden the weapons “to protect himself.”
“Then,” said Sir Michael, “for a considerable time, you lied and lied again.”
Mr Sutcliffe: “Yes.”
Sir Michael: “You had a ridiculous explanation about picking up people on the motorway.”
Mr Sutcliffe: “Ridiculous, yes.”
Sir Michael: “All to protect yourself?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “The mission.” Mr Sutcliffe added that after receiving a message from God he had told the police everything they wanted to know.
Sir Michael: “No, Mr Sutcliffe. The police were being perfectly friendly. With God’s message ringing in your ears, telling you to tell them everything, the first sentence you tell them is a lie.”
Mr Sutcliffe: “It is, yes… I interpreted it that God said ‘Tell everything’. I did not have a message.”
Sir Michael: “If God’s message was so clearly instructing you to tell the truth, why on Earth did it take you so long?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “On the contrary, I wanted to tell them as quickly as possible.”
Sir Michael pointed out that it was not until Mr Sutcliffe’s eighth interview with Dr Hugo Milne, a psychiatrist, that he mentioned his experience in the graveyard when the voice of God had spoken to him. He asked Mr Sutcliffe why he never mentioned it to the police.
Mr Sutcliffe replied: “Because I was waiting for a direct message saying that it was over, to fully convince me my mission was over.”
Sir Michael: “Did you ever get it?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “No.”
Sir Michael: “To this day you believe you are an agent for God on a mission which is only partially fulfilled?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “That’s right.” He added that he had not realised that he had told the doctors about his mission until “shortly afterwards.” His mission had been so secret that he had been unable to tell his girlfriend, his mother, his best friends, or a priest about “the most stunning thing” in his life.
Sir Michael asked Mr Sutcliffe about his Catholic upbringing and he agreed that he had learned about a great range of miracles involving “healing, restoring faith, comforting in sickness, and in loss.”
Sir Michael asked: “When did it first cross your mind that the God who spoke to you was rather evil, quite contrary to the sort of miracles you had been told about?”
Mr Sutcliffe replied that it seemed similar to the contradiction between the Old Testament and the New Testament. He agreed that he had developed his hatred of prostitutes before God had told him of his mission.
Sir Michael commented: “So God very conveniently jumped on the bandwagon and says ‘You have a divine mission, young Peter, to stalk the red light districts and avenge me by killing prostitutes?'”
Mr Sutcliffe said: “It’s a very colourful speech, sir, but it doesn’t apply.” He agreed that he had given different accounts to doctors about his injuries in a motorcycle accident. He denied making up symptoms to persuade doctors that he was ‘loony’.
Sir Michael asked him if he knew that his sentence might be different if he could he shown to be suffering from diminished responsibility. Mr Sutcliffe said he did not.
Sir Michael: “You are over 30 years of age, you read newspapers, you have a higher than average intelligence, and you have been murdering and attempting to murder people for years. There has been endless talk in pieces in the newspapers. Are you going now to turn round and tell members of the jury that on January 8 you had no idea what you were talking about?”
Mr Sutcliffe turned to the jury and said: “Yes, I had no idea it would be less if I got sent to a loony bin.”
Sir Michael asked him to explain the difference between his early version of the attack on Wilma McCann, when he told police that he killed her because he lost his temper; and his later version, when he told doctors that he had always intended to kill her and had left home with that purpose. “Was it because you realised that what you had said about McCann would not be of much help to you if you wanted to pull the wool over the doctors’ eyes?”
Mr Sutcliffe replied : “No: that wasn’t the reason.” He explained that he had not been telling the whole truth to the police. He denied hearing about a man called Mark Rowntree who was sent to Broadmoor after pleading guilty to manslaughter on grounds of diminished responsibility and then asking prison officers if he was at all like Rowntree.
Sir Michael challenged his claim that he believed all his victims to have been prostitutes. “Your story would have gone straight down the drain if you had to say to the doctors that six of them were not prostitutes.”
Mr Sutcliffe replied: “It’s not a story, sir.”
He also challenged Mr Sutcliffe’s particular claim that he did not realise Josephine Whitaker was not a prostitute when he attacked her. Had you got to the stage where your lust for killing meant that everybody that you saw, if in a quiet spot, could meet their death at your hands ?”
Mr Sutcliffe replied: “No.”
Sir Michael reminded the jury that Mr Sutcliffe had approached Miss Whitaker and told her “You can’t trust anyone these days.”
Sir Michael added ” Can you think of a more horrible and cynical thing to say to someone you were just about to murder ?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “No.”
Sir Michael: “Why did you say it?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “Because I couldn’t trust myself.”
Sir Michael: “You were trying to convince her she was quite safe with you?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “Yes. In a sense.”
Sir Michael: “Did God tell you to do that?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “No.”
Sir Michael: “It was a bit of private enterprise on your part, was it?”
Mr Sutcliffe agreed that his conversation with Miss Whitaker had been “a charade, a bit of macabre play-acting while you jockeyed her into position to kill her” but he insisted that God had been giving him detailed instructions while it was happening.
Sir Michael said he had sometimes inserted his knife several times into the same wound. “Do you realise how difficult it must have been to do that?” asked Sir Michael.
Mr Sutcliffe denied that he had done this.
As Sir Michael started to read from a pathologist’s report, Mr Sutcliffe interrupted, saying that he might have moved his knife about inside a wound. Sir Michael barked: “It hasn’t been challenged, Mr Sutcliffe, by your very experienced leading counsel.”
Why had be stabbed one of his victims in the vagina? Why had he so often stabbed his victims’ breasts? Weren’t these rather odd things to do? Was he getting sexual gratification from these injuries?
Sir Michael picked up a screwdriver: “This rusty old screwdriver that has been sharpened to this hideous point – how can you get that into the same place three times?”
Mr Sutcliffe replied that he had moved it about inside a wound. Sir Michael tossed the screwdriver down on the table. “Your case throughout has been ‘no sexual gratification, not doing it for lust or anything like that.'”
If it was true that he felt that, why had he sex with one of his victims, Helen Rytka? “You say you feel contaminated by the blood of a victim. You talk about your mission. And then surprise, surprise, here’s pretty little Helen Rytka and you have sex with her.”
Mr Sutcliffe said that he had had no choice. It had been important to keep her quiet because some taxi drivers had been close by.
Sir Michael said: “Of course you had a choice. God didn’t tell you to put your penis in that girl’s vagina.”
Mr Sutcliffe agreed but added that he now realised that he had not had an orgasm. He had been mistaken when he said this before.
Sir Michael then asked why on earth he had had to stab Jacqueline Hill in the eye. Mr Sutcliffe replied that her eyes had been staring at him in an accusing way.
“Did it matter whether she was giving you an accusing look ? You had God on your side. She was a mere mortal who you were about to take off the face of the earth.”
Mr Sutcliffe: “Despite being told what to do, still partly inside I felt guilty.”
Sir Michael: “So you felt sorry about what you were doing? I’m sure you don’t want to say that you enjoyed it.”
Mr Sutcliffe insisted that he had tried to kill mercifully.
Sir Michael said: “You mean to say that your victims never felt anything as they were lying there moaning, groaning, gurgling, a screwdriver in an eye, stabbed, and one disembowlled?”
Did he remember the case of disembowelling? Was that merciful? Had he ever had a favourite dog or cat? “Would you have ever killed them in any of the ways you killed these women?” asked Sir Michael.
“No,” came the reply.
Sir Michael suggested that his choice of site, his occasional ability to resist the demands of his voice, his quick thinking and play-acting during his attacks all suggested that he had great capacity for control.
Mr Sutcliffe denied this, and Sir Michael countered: “Are you saying that if the urge came over you in the middle of Piccadilly Circus, you would have done it there?”
“Yes,” replied Mr Sutcliffe. “That’s exactly what I said in my police statement.”
Sir Michael asked several times why he had never killed in his car. Mr Sutcliffe replied that it was impossible because there was no room. He repeated his answer several times and then, asked again, said: “They would probably make a lot of noise, and there would be evidence all over the car.”
“That’s it,” said Sir Michael. “Well done. Stop there. There would be blood all over the car. It would make your detection more likely. A messy job to get rid of it. That’s what I’m getting at: your capacity for control. Do you see?”
The judge interrupted to ask Sutcliffe why he had tried to decapitate one of his victims, Jean Jordan.
Mr Sutcliffe replied: “Because she was in league with the Devil, and between them they had hidden the £5 note, and I was going to do the same with her head.”
The judge pointed out that Sutcliffe had been unable to find the £5 and continued: “I don’t want to get into a theological argument, but are you saying that she and her colleague, the Devil, had beaten you and your God?”
Mr Sutcliffe replied: “It seemed very much so.”
Sir Michael: “Had you realised by about mid-February that you were not getting on too well in persuading these learned gentlemen that you were fit for a loony bin?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “No.”
Sir Michael: “And then did you say ‘Right. We’d better pull some more aces out of the pack?’ The mission was the floater and the bait on a hook was God, and they fell for it hook, line and sinker. Is that what happened?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “No.”
Re-examined by Mr Chadwin, Mr Sutcliffe said that he had never been told by any doctor that he could expect to be released from an asylum after only 10 years.
Had he told doctors that, if released, he would kill again Sutcliffe: “Yes, yes.”
Mr Chadwin: “What is your view about that now, Mr Sutcliffe?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “I still feel the same.”
Mr Chadwin: “Under what circumstances might you kill again?”
Mr Sutcliffe. “If I’m allowed out.”
Mr Chadwin: “Yes, but who would you kill if you were allowed out?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “Prostitutes.”
Mr Chadwin: “Why?”
Mr Sutcliffe: “Because I still do not believe the mission is finished.”
Mr Chadwin then called Dr Hugo Milne, forensic consultant psychiatrist at Bradford Hospital.
Dr Milne said that he had examined about 200 killers, acting for Crown or defence, and he was used to prisoners who tried to simulate illness. He said he believed that Mr Sutcliffe was not simulating illness. “He is suffering from schizophrenia of a paranoid type,” he added.
The case continues today.