Home Office blocks effective appeal by Chard

The Guardian, 13 May 1981

The Home Office has been accused of effectively blocking the appeal of Alan Chard, who was gaoled for 15 years for bank robbery after being convicted on the uncorroborated evidence of police informers.

The Home Secretary, Mr William Whitelaw, last month referred Mr Chard’s case back to the Appeal Court after one of the three informers who testified against him admitted to the Guardian that he had been pressed into lying in court.

Mr Chard’s supporters believed that this meant it was only a matter of time before Mr Chard was released. Now they fear that the Home Office has referred the case back to the court in a way which will make it impossible for Mr Chard to show his innocence when his appeal is heard bythe Lord Chief Justice, Lord Lane, on June 8.

Mr Stephen Ross, Liberal MP for the Isle of Wight, who has taken up Mr Chard’s Case, has asked for an immediate meeting with the Minister of state at the Home Office, Mr Patrick Mayhew, to discuss the referral.

He said: “My concern is that an innocent man may go back to prison because of an unsatisfactory referral which seems to ignore a large part of the case. I feel the Minister of State should be aware of this.”

The crux of the matter is whether the court will consider anything other than the statement made to the Guardian by Peter Wilding, the informer who admitted that he lied.

After his conviction in November 1975, Mr Chard protested his innocence and, with another inmate in Prison, Jim Colla, he produced a 52,000-word dossier of new evidence and new analysis of old evidence. Mr Chard and Mr Colla believe that this shows the prosecution case to be untenable.

But the Home Office referral is exclusively concerned with the Guardian story about Peter Wilding. It does not mention the Colla/Chard dossier.

In a letter to Mr Mayhew this week Mr Colla told him: “The Chard case does not rest on what Wilding alone said. He was the last-minute icing. You have chosen to take this icing and present it to the court minus the cake, fully aware that without a complete referral of all the evidence given by all three of the witnesses the appeal is doomed.”

Mr. Colla has said that he will start a private prosecution against the three informers if the appeal fails.