Peter Sutcliffe told police that he had been able to cover his tracks after several attacks because his wife gave false alibis for him without realising it, an Old Bailey jury heard yesterday when his trial on 13 murder charges continued.
Mr Sutcliffe had been interviewed on nine occasions between 1975 and 1980, often because his car had been seen in red-light districts around the time when killings occurred. But his wife had supported his story that he had been at home with her.
He told police after his arrest: “I must stress that these occasions were usually weeks, sometimes months, after the particular events. In these cases I was able to satisfy the police because my wife would automatically agree that we would be home, as we were practically all of the time anyway.”
Mr Sutcliffe has admitted the manslaughter of 13 women but has denied murdering them.
The first half of yesterday’s hearing was taken up with detailed study of police statements which had already been read to the jury. Counsel for both sides questioned the officers involved. They agreed that Mr Sutcliffe had been co-operative and “in-credibly calm” while he was being questioned.
He had been unable to tell them exactly which hammer or knife or screwdriver he had used on each attack. He had kept all his weapons in a pile in his garage. “I didn’t choose one,” he had told police. “I just picked one up.” He thought the sharpened screwdriver which he had used was “a horrible looking thing.”
Mr Sutcliffe’s counsel, Mr James Chadwin QC, took the officers through the statements, stopping at the references which his client had made to his mental state at the time of the attacks: “Killing prostitutes became an obsession… The urge was so strong, I had gone out of my mind… The urge to kill girls was practically uncontrollable… I was in a world of my own.”
He also picked out Mr Sutcliffe’s description of his feelings as he approached one of his victims, Vera Millward. “It sounds a bit evil now,” he had said. “There I was walking along, with my hammer and a big Phillips screwdriver in my pocket, ready to do the inevitable.”
The court also heard his account of the incident in 1969 when he had been caught near a prostitute’s house with a hammer and had subsequently been convicted of going equipped for theft. He had said it was part of his hatred for a particular prostitute who had cheated him out of £10.
“I was over the brink and had it in mind to kill her but I never saw her again, and it developed into a general loathing for prostitutes.” He had never told police his real reason for being there with a hammer. ” I didn’t tell them because to tell them would be a far worse charge than I was charged with at the time.”
He also had told officers of the motorcycle crash in 1965 or 1966 after which he says he began to feel ill. “I was left with severe bouts of morbid depression. I used to subject to hallucinations just seeing things that aren’t there and getting strange noises in my head, humming and burring.
“I used to think I was hearing things and I started conversing with myself. When I had these sort of attacks, I knew what I was doing but I had this inner conflict. My mind was in a haze, and I didn’t know what was right or wrong. I didn’t know whether I was acting rationally or not.”
Later he had related this to his confusion over the killings. “The inner torment was unimaginable because, strange as it may seem. I didn’t want to kill anyone at all. I just had to get rid of all the prostitutes, like it or not.”
Mr John Leach, a prison officer in the hospital wing of Armley Prison, Leeds, where Mr Sutcliffe was taken after his arrest, told of meetings be witnessed between Mr Sutcliffe and his wife, Sonia. He said that at that stage Mr Sutcliffe was being kept under 24-hour observation.
Of one visit, about a week after Mr Sutcliffe’s arrest, Mr Leach commented: “Mrs Sutcliffe used to run the visits, she used to take the lead… She used to bring pieces of paper with itemised things on them and run through them quickly because she only had a limited amount of time.” He said they were personal mattes between Sutcliffe and his wife.
“One day Sutcliffe said (to Sonia) ‘I would feel no animosity towards you if you want to lead a life of your own, because I am going to live for 30 years in prison unless I can convince people in here that I’m mad – then maybe 10 years in a loony bin.” Mr Leach said he thought it odd that Mr Sutcliffe should use the phrase “loony bin” since it was a southern word, not used in Yorkshire.
Under cross-examination from Mr Chadwin, Mr Leach said that Mrs Sutcliffe used to dominate their meetings. Of one meeting he had written in the log book officers kept: “A little less frantic than previous visits from his wife, but she completely overwhelms and dominates him in the situation.”
Mr Chadwin then read other entries from the log book. On January 6 one read: “… boasts about his near-misses with police, eg having blood all over his hands and being chased by police. Says does not go out intentionally to kill, but has compulsion to.”
.Another entry read: “Very confused. Seems to lose track of time. Seems to think he been in here longer than he has.” :t times he was said to “fluctuate from being talkative and very quiet, sometimes sitting with a book in front of him, not reading, just staring into space.”
Another prison officer, Mr Anthony Fitzpatrick, told how in April Mr Sutcliffe was discussing with him the possibility of spending time in a long term prison. “Mr Sutcliffe said: ‘I’m not going to a long-term gaol. I’m going to Park Lane. A bed has been reserved for me.” (It was explained that Park Lane is a special hospital.)
“He said an agreement had been reached between the defence and prosecution for a plea of diminished responsibility to be accepted,” said Mr Fitzpatrick. “His solicitor had told him this. A psychiatrist had told him he would have to do no more than 10 years to satisfy the public.”
Cross-examined, Mr Fitzpatrick said Mr Sutcliffe was “arrogantly confident that his plea of diminished responsibility would be accepted.”
A third officer, Mr Frederick Edwards, said Mr Sutcliffe had been very happy with the news in April that his trial was to be at the Old Bailey and not in Leeds. “He was saying to me that the doctors considered him disturbed and he was quite amused by this. He was smiling broadly and rocking back in his chair and said ‘I’m as normal as anyone.'”
The trial was adjourned until Monday.