Sutcliffe describes killing for God

The Guardian, 7 May 1981

Sir Michael Havers, prosecuting, began the second day of the trial by describing how Peter Sutcliffe’s last victim, Jacqueline Hill, aged 20, met her death.

On the evening she died, Jacqueline, a Leeds University student, was returning from a meeting of voluntary probation workers in Leeds city centre which finished at 9 p.m. She was last seen alive getting off a bus near her lodgings in Alma Road. The next morning she was found behind a car park, with her bra pulled over her head and her jeans and pants pulled down.

A post-mortem showed a wound to one breast, five lacerations to the head which had caused fractures and a stab wound in the right eye which had penetrated one and a half inches. “The pathologist took the view that the girl did not necessarily die at once,” said Sir Michael.

At about 10 p.m. on the night of her murder an Iraqi student found Jacqueline’s bloodstained handbag at the entrance to some waste land and called the police. They searched a nearby derelict house but did not discover her glasses or mittens, which were found the next morning. Sir Michael said: “It was a filthy night, very windy and raining and probably difficult for these things to be seen. Although they may be open to criticism, nothing turns on it because by the time they got there the girl was clearly dead.”

In a statement, Sutcliffe allegedly said: “I stabbed her in the lungs. Her eyes were wide open and she seemed to be looking at me with an accusing stare. It shook me up a bit, so I jabbed a screwdriver into her eye.”

Sir Michael then went on to describe Sutcliffe’s arrest whilst in his car with a Sheffield prostitute, Olivia Reivers. He had paid her £10 and had driven to an area frequented by prostitutes, where he had said “Do you mind if I talk to you for a bit?” He had explained that he had an argument with his wife – “something about not being able to go with her.”

Ms Reivers then took off her knickers and Sutcliffe tried but failed to get an erection. While she was trying to arouse him, a car drew up and Sutcliffe saw that it was the police. He said to her: “Pretend you’re my girlfriend.”

While police questioned her, he went off to urinate nearby. Police who interviewed him in the early hours of January 3 said that he must have told them lies during previous interviews, when he had claimed he was not a ‘punter’ (someone who goes with prostitutes). He replied that he had been with Miss Reivers because he was depressed by his wife’s constant nagging.

Sir Michael said that the next 24 hours were crucial in the police investigation. That evening the scene of the arrest was searched again, and a hammer and a knife were discovered near the spot where Sutcliffe had gone to urinate.

In another interview, Det Inspector Boyle referred to Sutcliffe urinating against the wall and said “I think you went there for another purpose”

Sutcliffe: “I think you have been leading up to it.”

Boyle: “What?”

Sutcliffe: “The Yorkshire Ripper.”

Boyle: “What about the Yorkshire Ripper?”

Sutcliffe: “Well, it’s me.”

Sutcliffe was said to have continued: “ I am glad that it is all over. I would have killed that girl in Sheffield if I wasn’t caught. But I want to tell my wife myself. It is her I am thinking about – and my family. I am not bothered about myself.”

Asked how many women he had killed, he said eleven. He said that he had not done “that one at Preston” and that he was not the author of the tapes and letter that had been sent to the police. “While that was going on I felt safe,” he said.

He said he knew the names of all his victims. “They are all in my brain, reminding me of the beast I am.” Later he admitted that he had killed 12 women. “Just thinking about them all reminds me of the monster I am. I would have gone on and on, but now I am glad I have been caught.”

Wilma McCann:

Sutcliffe said that he was driving through Leeds late at night “in quite a good mood”. He picked up a woman who was just thumbing for a lift. Just before we set off she asked ‘did I want business’. I didn’t know what she meant and asked her to explain to me. And, in a scornful voice she said : “Bloody hell, do I have to spell it out to you?” as though it were a challenge. “My reaction was to go with her.” He paid her £5, but said “I was a bit suprised, I expected it to be a bit romantic.” Sutcliffe said he needed time to get aroused, but she replied : “I am going. It’s going to take you all fucking day. You are fucking useless.” Sutcliffe said he suddenly felt a ‘seething rage’ and followed her into a field, having taken a hammer out of his tool box. “She sat down on a coat and unfastened her trousers and said, “Come on, get it over with.” I said “Don’t worry, I will.” I then hit her with the hammer on the top of the head.” Sutcliffe then went back to the car but could see her arm still moving. He returned with a knife and began stabbing her in a ‘blind panic’. He said that he returned to his mother-in-law’s house where he was living, washed his hands and went to bed. “After that time I developed and played up a hatred of prostitutes in order to justify within myself why I had attacked and killed Wilma Mcann”

Emily Jackson:

Sutcliffe picked her up in Leeds. “I remembered there was an overpowering smell of cheap perfume and sweat,” he said. “This served me to hate the woman even more… Looking back, I can can see the first murder unhinged me completely. I knew from the outset I didn’t want intercourse with her. I just wanted to get rid of her.” He pretended that there was something wrong with his car and while she was leaning over the bonnet, helping him, he hit her head with a hammer. (Sir Michael commented : ” Can you imagine an account which sets our more carefully the deliberate way in which he manoeuvred her into a position where he could hit her ? Everything was so well planned.”) He said he pulled her bra up and pulled down her pants. “To be honest, I pulled up her clothing to satisfy some sort of sexual revenge on her,” he said. He returned to his mother-in-law’s house with a feeling of “satisfaction and justification.”

Irene Richardson:

“I drove to Leeds to find a prostitute to make it one more less.” They had driven to a park, where she asked if she could urinate before sex. He hit her while she was crouching and then slashed her lower abdomen and throat. “By this time,” he told police, ” killing prostitutes had become an obsession with me. I couldn’t stop myself. It was some sort of drug.”

Patricia Atkinson:

Sutcliffe had seen her swearing at a driver in Bradford and had picked her up. They went back to her flat, where he hit her with a claw hammer. “It was the first time I had noticed red blood. Before it had always been dark. She made horrible gurgle noises when I hit her.”

Jayne MacDonald:

“This next one I still feel terrible about,” he said. “I read recently about her father dying of a broken heart and it brought it all back to me. I realised what a monster I was. I thought she was a prostitute…. I felt like somebody inhuman and I realised it was the Devil turning me.” He said when people talked about the Ripper killings he was able to divorce it from his mind and could discuss it normally.

Maureen Long:

He picked her up after she had been out dancing and drove just past her house to some waste land. He hit her while she was urinating and stabbed her. The next day he heard his victim was still alive. “I thought it was the end of the line there and then.” He realised that things were ” hotting up ” in Leeds and Bradford and wanted to tell someone what he was doing, but was worried about the effect on his wife and family. He decided it was safer in Manchester.

Jean Jordan:

He picked her up in Moss Side. “I suppose this was the biggest mistake she ever made.” He paid her £5 and they drove to some allotments, where he attacked her “until the moaning stopped.” There were a number of cars about, so he drove off. On the way home he realised that he could be traced by the brand new £5 note. When it became clear that the body had not been discovered he returned after nine days and desperately searched the body for the money. He tried to decapitate the head with a hacksaw, intending to “make a big mystery about it” but had been unable to. He was convinced that his time was up because of the £5 note. “I read about the note being traced to a Shipley bank, but by some miracle I escaped detection.”

Marilyn Moore:

She was picked up in Leeds and driven to a muddy land. Sutcliffe slipped in the mud as he hit her head with a hammer. She started screaming, and, worried about people nearby, he drove off “with a lot of wheel spin.”

Yvonne Pearson:

“This was the one time I was genuinely going home, but I still had my hammer under my seat.” Sutcliffe said that she just tapped on his window as he was driving past. He took her to waste ground, hit her twice and pulled her behind an old settee. When a car approached he stuffed filling from the settee into her mouth and down her throat. “I was senseless with rage and kicked away furiously.”

Helen Rytka:

“The urge to kill girls was now practically unendurable.” They went to a timber yard and as she went to get in the back of the car he tried to hit her, but struck the edge of the car. “She said ‘What is that? ‘ I replied ‘Just a small sample of one of these’ and hit her furiously over the head. She just crumpled, making loud moaning noises.”

Vera Millward:

Sutcliffe paid £5 and drove to hospital grounds in Manchester, where he hit her over the head and slashed her stomach open. “The feelings I had came welling up and each time they were more random and indiscriminate. I realised I now had an urge to kill any woman.” (Sir Michael pointed out that Sutcliffe had told doctors that he believed throughout that all his victims were prostitutes.)

Josephine Whitaker:

“The mood was in me. No woman was safe while I was in this state of mind… I realised Josephine was not a prostitute but at that time I wasn’t bothered. I just wanted to kill a woman.”

Barbara Leach:

“My urge to kill remained strong and I was totally out of control.” He said he was acting like an automaton as he hit her over the head and stabbed her with a screwdriver. The statement did not mention the next three charges but passed straight to the last.

Jacqueline Hill:

“By this time I was in a world of my own.” After hitting her and stabbing her in the lungs he noticed she was staring, so he stabbed her in the eye. (Sir Michael commented : “Remember the evidence of the post-mortem that she may not have died straight away.”) Sir Michael said that Sutcliffe’s statement was the most detailed account of murder and attempted murder he had ever read, though it lacked any reference to other offences committed by him. When charged with the murder of Jacqueline Hill, Sutcliffe replied: “I am terribly sorry about this tragic loss to her family and friends. I would do anything to alter what had happened. I am glad I was apprehended because I was totally out of my mind when I committed this and other acts.” Sir Michael said that he would give the jury copies of the report from Dr Milne, the Bradford psychiatrist who examined Sutcliffe 11 times. It would be up to the defence to call medical evidence. The hearing continue today.

Peter Sutcliffe’s view of himself was that he was easygoing, had plenty of friends, and was sometimes over-generous, according to a psychiatrist’s report presented in court. Mr Justice Boreham briefly halted proceedings to ask whether it was correct for the crown court to present the report when it really formed part of the defence case.

“I’m a little troubled about it being done at this stage,” he said. He allowed it to be read only after counsel for both sides said that it was the most convenient time. The report, which was written by Dr Hugo Milne, the consultant forensic psychiatrist at Bradford hospital opened with a description of Mr. Sutcliffe’s family.

Dr Milne added: “The mother became involved with a policeman and as a result the happy marriage was destroyed and the father became unfaithful to the woman with whom he is now living.” The mother had died on November 8th 1978. Dr Milne wrote: “It’s quite apparent that her death distressed him greatly. It’s also apparent that he was very much fonder of his mother than of his father.”

His relationship with his family had become much more difficult since his arrest, because his wife, Sonia, objected to them visiting because they had been talking to the press. She was very critical of her parents- in-law.

Mr. Sutcliffe was a devout Roman Catholic until he left secondary school, aged 15. Since his arrest he had made contact with the Roman Catholic priest in Armley Prison, Leeds. He had left school without academic qualifications and had had 11 jobs, most recently as a heavy goods vehicle driver in Bradford.

He had met his wife, Sonia, when she was only 16 and still at school, in 1967. Two years before their marriage, in 1972, she had become mentally ill and was diagnosed as a schizophrenic. She suffered with delusions and was excitable. She had spent three weeks in hospital and had to give up her teacher training.

She had shown no signs of a recurrence of her illness, but in interviews with Dr Milne “she readily admits that she had been temperamental and difficult at times and freely admits that she has frequently teased and provoked her husband.”

Mr. Sutcliffe had said she often shouted at him, so loudly he was embarrassed in case the neighbours heard. Both husband and wife agreed that their sex life was entirely satisfactory. Dr Milne added that he had been particularly careful to look for a sexual component in the killings. He was satisfied that neither Mr nor Mrs Sutcliffe was sexually deviant. They had no children because they were more concerned to be able to buy material things. Mr Sutcliffe had denied feeling any sexual excitement during the killings. “He completely denies that he was using the assaults to help him in his sexual situation. There is no suggestion that he is a sadistic sexual deviant.”

Dr Milne added that he had found Sutcliffe friendly and open, although he had withheld information from a prison doctor who had suggested that Sonia was stupid if she maintained that she knew nothing about the killings. He had first experienced symptoms of his long standing, paranoid schizophrenic illness while he was working as a grave digger in Bingley Cemetery, particularly in the Catholic end.

Dr Milne’s report quoted Sutcliffe’s own description of what happened. “It appeared to be coming from the top of the cross. It was an echoing voice, vague and distant, but it repeated itself some two or three times. It was direct from the stone itself. It had a really strange effect. I felt I was privileged to hear it. I went back to the stone several times but I never heard it again. I had quite a lot of messages. I have had all kinds of words and messages since.

“When I have been on this sequence of killings I have heard ‘God giveth and God taketh life’ and ‘God works in mysterious ways’ and odd comments as normal conversation to encourage me to kill, to kill and wipe out all the people called scum who cannot justify themselves in society.”

In other interviews with Dr Milne, Sutcliffe had spoken of his fears that Sonia was having an affair with another man while they were courting. He had argued with her and walked off in an angry and resentful frame of mind. Later that day he had seen a prostitute soliciting and felt attracted to her. He had picked her up, re-turned to her flat, but had not had sex. He had asked for his £10 back and she had said she would take him to a garage to get some change. But she had duped him. A man had appeared and made threatening remarks. “From this moment on he became consumed with hatred for prostitutes,” said Dr Milne.

Dr Milne commented that Mr Sutcliffe had had sex with only one of his victims. He felt that his experience in the cemetery had marked the onset of schizophrenia, marked by auditory hallucinations, distortion of perception in his view of the gravestone, and schizophrenic neologisms, ie the invention of new words.

He said that God had given him the means to kill and had kept him out of trouble. Dr Milne asked him why he was in custody. “I may deserve a rest, or he may have chosen someone else. But I have heard God since I have been here. It seems like God has chosen to put me here.”

Asked about the hoax tapes received by police on the Ripper inquiry, he had said : “God has another disciple. I’m fairly convinced. No tapes for a while. My mission is halted for a while. I might carry on shortly. The other fellow may send more tapes. God may have stopped.”

Sir Michael Havers told the jury that the Crown did not accept Dr Milne’s view that Mr Sutcliffe was acting out of diminished responsibility when he killed. “If it was the compelling reason for this man’s murderous conduct over five and a half years that he was acting under the will and control of God and started it with a vision and it then became a mission, ask yourselves: why did it take so long to tell the doctors?” Sir Michael said.