Doctors divide over ethics of psychosurgery

The Guardian, 3 April 1981

“Come The Day of Judgement, one of the sins to which I shall have to abjectly confess is that in the early 1950s I recommended the operation in about 20 cases. But never again. Nothing will convince me that the operation is ever anything but unethical.

“I make this bold statement because I believe that to perform a destructive, irreversible operation on the brain, an organ of such infinite complexity and delicacy is like kicking a malfunctioning computer in the hope that by so doing its efficiency will be restored.”

The operation to which Dr Henry Rollin was referring when he wrote these words in the privately-circulated Prison Medical Journal last year is the pre-frontal Ieucotomy or lobotomy, the best known form of psychosurgery.

Psychosurgery is still performed in British hospitals, although it is banned in the Soviet Union and much of Eastern Europe; and permissible in some of the United States only under strictly controlled circumstances. The World Health Organisation has described it as “at least ethically doubtful.”

An array of pressure groups – including MIND, the Royal College of Psychiatrists, and the Scientologists’ organisation, the Citizens’ Commission on Human Rights – is pressing hard for the Department of Health to change the law to ban or restrict the use of psychosurgery in Britain.

Yet the issue remains confused among conflicting facts, theories and ethical principles. The confusion is so bad that a woman psychiatrist who had the operation and believed that she was recovered was then refused a job by other psychiatrists who did not believe in it.

In a book on psychosurgery to be published later this year, Dr Douglas Carroll and Mr Mark O’Callaghan criticise the lack of hard evidence about it. “Anecdotal testimonies of dramatic cure; bizarre assessment procedures; unsophisticated and casual methods of follow-up; and amateur statistics are far from untypical,” they write.

The case against psychosurgery rests largely on the inability of the psychosurgeons themselves to produce any statistical proof in their defence. They also fail to explain why the operation might work, or even to agree on how it should be performed.

Some patients claim that the operation has made them worse. Others start to suffer from epileptic fits.

In a paper delivered to the Royal Society of Medicine in 1972, Dr Paul Bridges said that the operation performed at his hospital, the Brook in south London, could cause irritability, lethargy, and outspokenness. “Such, effects can be a nuisance in a very few cases,” he said, “but are almost never socially disabling.”

The latest figures released by the Department of Health show that Dr Bridges and a neurosurgeon, Mr John Banlett, performed 47 operations at the Brook in 1979. Only 23 others were performed in the whole of England, at a number of different hospitals.

Critics of the operation often cite the fact that surgeons are unable to agree on how to perform it. At different hospitals they operate on 14 different parts of the brain with 16 different lesions.

Many surgeons still use the old ‘freehand’ method of cutting into the brain. It was this which was partly responsible for the demise of the old-fashioned frontal lobotomy, when surgeons simply inserted a blunt knife into the patient’s temple and sliced downwards, separating the frontal lobes from the rest of the brain. Many patients became vegetables.

The freehand technique is never used at the Brook where the ‘stereotactic’ method, developed by Dr Geoffrey Knight in the 1960s, is used. This involves clamping a calibrated metal gauge on to the patient’s skull so that the surgeon can line up with pinpoint accuracy the point in the brain at which he is aiming.

The stereotactic device has failed only once, when a patient died after a senior registrar at the Brook made a mathematical miscalculation and slipped the tiny radioactive rods of Yttrium 90 in to the wrong part of the brain.

Critics also cite the wide range of conditions which are treated with the operation. The Brook concentrates on depression and anxiety, but others have been operating on sexual conditions, including homosexuality; the aggressive or psychotic; schizophrenics; and, in the United States, on hyper-energetic children.

Dr Bridges explained last week that his unit deals only with patients who are suffering from inherited depression. He said that he had no doubt that depression could be a physical illness caused by an inherited enzyme. This provided the theoretical basis for the operation.

But Dr Douglas Carroll, who lectures in psychology at Birmingham University, said: “That is a terribly loose argument and a very hard one to defend. There are so many theories of depression, ranging from the chemical to the sociological. We are still at the speculative stage.”

Dr Bridges frankly admitted that he had no statistical proof that the operation worked. “We do think we know what we are doing, within the limits of medicine – and medicine can be very vague sometimes.”

There are signs that despite all the criticism, some psychosurgeons are feeling a new confidence in their operation. Last week the Brook broke with its previous policy of self-conscious secrecy and allowed a small number of invited journalists and observers from the Department of Health and the Royal College of Psychiatrists to visit the unit.

Dr Bridges said: “Everybody has been telling us that we must tell the public what has been going on here, but we’ve always thought that it’s none of their business, really, and that what goes on is just between the doctor and the patient.”

The defence of the operation which was mounted at the open day centred on the simple, repeated assertion that patients who were gravely ill – so chronically depressed that they could not even speak – had recovered to lead normal lives.

Dr Bridges showed a video of interviews with some of the patients before the operation: a woman of 77 who lay shaking and gasping and muttering that she wanted to die; a middle-aged woman who believed that she was going to harm all the babies in the world and sat wailing “I’ve done terrible harm. It’s terrible.”

Patients who had been brought along for the open day all agreed that the operation had helped them, although they conceded that they were among the lucky ones who had made 100 per cent recoveries from depression.

A former Thames lighterman who had retired and sunk into a depression in which he neither spoke nor ate, said that his life now meant something to him again. “I couldn’t stand having nothing to do,” he said. “But now I rather enjoy it, not having to go to work or anything.”

Dr Bridges is proud of his record, even though his precise success rate is hard to establish. He stresses that the Brook’s stereotactic operation is far more refined than the old lobotomies which so fired Dr Rollin when he wrote in the Prison Medical Journal.

Dr Rollin said last week that he stood by his views on the operation. But he added: “I would not be so dictatorial or arrogant as to say that there is no place for psychosurgery today in its refined form. But if there is a place for it, then I don’t know what it is.”

The powerful testimony of Dr Bridge’s successful patients is not accepted at its face value by critics of the operation. Dr Carroll said: “It’s not enough to just look and say: ‘Oh, he’s talking and he’s not having convulsions so he’s all right.’ It needs a much subtler approach. Then you find a number of intellectual, cognitive and psychological problems.”

Most of the critics are now trying to persuade the Department of Health to set up some form of preview panel, composed of doctors, lawyers and others, to monitor the progress of patients. It would have the right to stop an operation taking place where there was doubt about its suitability or about the patient’s ability to consent.

Surgeons concede that it is often impossible to get effective free consent from patients who are too deeply depressed to communicate and too desperate to care. As one patient said to MIND’s legal officer, Mr Larry Gostin: “I was in such a state that I would have consented if they said they wanted to cut my head off.”

Dr Bridges, like other consultants and surgeons, is not keen on having a panel of outsiders intruding on his work. “If the public wants one, we will have to have one,” he said, ” but I can’t see how it will help me or the patient.”

 

** One man who had psychosurgery at the Brook hospital in south London said last week that he was claiming £50,000 compensation from the South East Thames Regional Health Authority. Mr Robert Edwicker. aged 56, says that the operation – a stereotactic subcaudate tractotomy – has changed his personality.

“I get so erratic,” he said. “I go out of the house to do something, and my memory goes, and I can’t remember what I have gone out to do. I get aggressive. Sometimes I just have to stop inside, otherwise I’d probably be arrested. If anybody speaks to me, I’m just as likely to stick one on them. It’s a terrible situation.”

Mr Edwicker first became ill while he was with the Marines during the war. He suffered from anxiety, complicated by a stomach complaint. He had a series of operations and was then put on a course of Dexedrine. He became addicted to it.

His operation was performed in 1969 by Dr Geoffrey Knight, the father of modern psychosurgery, to try to cure his addiction. Dr Knight’s successor at the Brook, Dr Paul Bridges, said that the unit no longer performs the operation on addicts and alcoholics.

Dr Bridges said last week that he did not believe that Mr Edwicker’s aggression or memory loss had anything to do with his operation. “I have never known it with any of our other patients,” he said. The case is not expected to come to court until next year.