The Home Office is considering using the royal prerogative of mercy to free Alan Chard, who was sentenced to 12 years’ imprisonment in 1975 on the evidence of a police informer who has now told the Guardian that he was lying.
The case is being studied by a section of the Home Office’s Criminal Department which specialises in advising on the use of the prerogative. “The Chard file is very much on the table,” a senior official said last night.
Mr Patrick Mayhew, Minister of State at the Home Office, is expected to announce a decision this week.
Mr Stephen Ross, the Liberal MP for the Isle of Wight, who has been pressing the Home Office to review Mr Chard’s case, has put down a Commons motion, asking the Home Secretary, Mr Whitelaw, to either release Mr Chard or refer his case back to the Court of Appeal.
Mr Ross also intends to ask the Commons Select Committee on Home Affairs to investigate the history and role of supergrass informers.
Mr Chard was convicted on three charges of conspiring to rob banks on the uncorroborated evidence of three informers who took part in one of Scotland Yard’s largest supergrass operation.
One of the informers, Peter Wilding, has admitted in a statement to the Guardian that he had never met Mr Chard and that he lied about him under pressure from the other informers. A copy of Mr Wilding’s statement has been sent to the Home Office.
The Home Office also has a 52,000-word file on the case, produced by a former cell-mate of Mr. Chard, Jim Colla; and a report by police who reviewed the case last year but did not interview Mr Wilding.
Mr Chard’s mother, Mrs Sarah Chard, said last night: “He has never lost hope. He always used to tell me not to worry because he was innocent. But the strain has been very bad for his nerves. It’s all boiling up inside him, and he has it on his mind all the time. I just hope now that they know the truth that they will let him go.”