The ‘supergrass’ operation which jailed an innocent man

The Guardian, 2 March 1981

Peter Wilding was stuck in a traffic jam in Hounslow on the afternoon of September 26 1974. A man walked up to the car and asked directions. “I looked down at his map and, the next thing I knew, there were police officers climbing all over my car.”

He was not completely surprised. Two months earlier he had helped a team of violent men to steal £10,000 from Barclays Bank in St John’s Wood, London. He had been paid £500 for showing them the bank and its lay out. A policeman had been shot and wounded.

But what followed in the months after his arrest culminated in his joining a conspiracy to imprison an innocent man, Alan Chard. After his arrest Peter Wilding was taken to Chiswick police station. “I was told they wanted me in connection with the attempted murder of a police officer.”

Unknown to Wilding, Chiswick police station was already playing host to one of his accomplices on the St John’s Wood robbery, Billy Williams. But Williams’s treatment was somewhat gentler, because he had agreed to tell the police everything he knew.

He was later to sell his story to a newspaper, replete with details and photographs of his cell with its colour television and of his drinking parties with officers. He revelled in the title Squealer Billy, Duke of Chiswick.

His privileges included almost continual access to other prisoners in the station. Within 48 hours he was renewing his acquaintance with Peter Wilding and inviting him to his cell to watch television and talk about the case. Records of the men’s statements show an extraordinary change.

Billy Williams had already been in custody for six weeks. He had made 24 statements and never referred even obliquely to Alan Chard. On the day of Wilding’s arrest, in his 25th statement, he mentioned ‘a bloke called Alan’ as a potential recruit for the St John’s Wood robbery.

Five days later this became a new, full-blooded allegation. In a statement on October 1, Williams told police: “Alan Chard was the supplier of the hand guns used on the robberies… Chard has told me verbally he can get any type of gun.”

On the same day that Williams made that damning statement, Alan Chard was arrested and held at Chiswick police station for four days. By this stage, Peter Wilding had started making his first tentative references to Mr Chard in interviews with the police. The interviews would stop and start repeatedly.

“A lot of the time when I was making statements, Billy Williams was next door, and they were going to him and then coming back and telling me other little things that went on. I know he was there because I saw him go by a couple of times.”

On a few occasions Billy Williams even sat in the interview room to prompt Mr Wilding. The whole process took on a new vigour when Alan Chard was arrested. “They used to show him to me every day. They’d take me along to his cell door and open the hatch, and I could see him lying on the bed, looking up at the ceiling. They’d say: ‘Is that the guy?’ and I’d say: ‘No. I never seen him before’.”

He would be taken back to Billy Williams’s cell. “I told him: ‘That ain’t the geezer’, and he said: ‘You know it is.'” When Wilding insisted that Alan Chard was a complete stranger, Billy Williams used a persuasive new tactic: he threatened to implicate Wilding in a conspiracy to rob a warehouse in Sussex.

Williams actually went on to give the police a detailed account of this conspiracy, including in the team “Peter who looked after the guns on the St John’s Wood robbery.” The conspiracy was supposed to have happened in 1972, yet Williams had not met Wilding until 1974 and had earlier told the police this.

The factual weakness of the statement was irrelevant to Peter Wilding. “Billy told me I had to say it all about Chard or I’d end up involved in something else. I said : ‘All right.’ All I wanted to do was to get out of the fucking police station. He said if I helped him he wouldn’t put me into anything else.

“He used to talk to me and say this happened and that happened, and I would write it down. I couldn’t believe what was going on. I couldn’t get away from him. If I didn’t go across to see him at night, they would bring him across to see me.

“Even after I left the station on bail I used to go back and see Billy, just to make sure that nothing was going be done, that he wasn’t sticking me up for anything else. I used to run errands for him. I used to go and get his kebabs.”

Wilding also knew from the police that they were prepared charge him with robbing the bank at St John’s Wood and attempting to murder the police officer who was shot then. “I was right out of my league,” he said.

The insistent pressure paid off. By the time Alan Chard came to trial in the autumn of 1975, Wilding was giving a detailed account of Chard’s involvement in three bank robberies. Billy Williams and another of the team who turned Queen’s Evidence, Jimmy Trusty, were doing the same.

Peter Wilding’s statement this weekend that he lied about Mr Chard is by no means the only evidence of the conspiracy between the grasses at Chiswick police station. A wealth of other material has been unearthed by the extraordinarily dogged energies of Alan Chard’s former cell mate, Jim Colla.

Alan Chard had been in the Paratroop Regiment in Aden and Cyprus until he was discharged with a good character in 1955. He had a record of petty crime, assault and one major conviction for robbery and possession of gelignite, for which he was sentenced to eleven years’ imprisonment in July 1966.

Colla cheerfully admits to a long career as a con man, usually devoted to swindling garages out of expensive cars. He also tried his hand at emptying warehouses, and in 1976 he was sentenced to five years in prison for it

In Parkhurst he met Alan Chard and got to know him by playing marathon games of Scrabble. He was aware that Chard was writing to people who might help him to prove his innocence and failing to persuade them that he was a worthy cause.

Jim Colla said: “I came to dread the days when replies such as this were received by Alan, for he would work himself up into such a state that there could be little hope of a decent game of Scrabble. He was on tranquilisers, stomach pills and sleeping tablets. He was going to pieces.”

The two men spent six months wading through the paperwork of Alan Chard’s trial. At the end of it they believed they could prove that each of the informers had been lying. They showed them contradicting each other, themselves and objective fact.

One of their proudest moments was a handwriting analysis of a page from a hotel registration book in Guernsey, a copy of which had been sent to them in Parkhurst at their request. It proved that two of the main figures in the team of bank robbers, Billy Williams and Philip Trusty, had been at the hotel on three days in July, 1974.

This meant crucially that Philip Trusty could not have been in London sitting in a pub buying guns from Alan Chard on any of those days. So it undermined the version of events given by Billy Williams and Philip Trusty’s own brother, Jimmy.

This had not come out at the trial because the two men had registered at the hotel under false names. They had failed to meet each other as arranged, and each said that he was the only one who had been there. The jury could not be sure that Philip Trusty was really in the hotel and so they could not be sure that he was not buying guns from Alan Chard.

Similarly, the two men established an alibi for Alan Chard which wrought havoc with the accounts of Billy Williams and Peter Wilding on two of the conspiracy charges which Alan Chard faced. They established that on July 24 and 25 of 1974, when he was supposed to have been suggesting one bank robbery and visiting the proposed scene of another, he was really in a motel in Wales.

The motel’s registration book had been produced at the trial. But the prosecution suggested that a friend of Chard’s had taken the book and driven it halfway to London so that Chard could meet him on the motorway, sign the book, and return to London in time to take part in the two conspiracies.

They had also suggested that the alibi was inadequate since he could have engaged in the conspiracies on other days around that period, so that even if he really had been in Wales it would not help him.

However, from their cell at Parkhurst, Colla and Chard recruited witnesses, including a former mayor of Swansea, who were willing to testify that Chard really had been at the motel that night. Then, by simple deduction, they showed that the informers’ version of the conspiracies made no sense unless they occurred on July 24 and 25.

Jim Colla later wrote about how he felt as the detective work progressed: “I reached the point where I felt I knew these men. It had become a personal battle of wits between myself and them to the point where I sudddenly found I was reading a passage aloud and asking the wall: ‘Why are you saying that, you lying bastard?'”

Jimmy Trusty made a series of detailed statements about a meeting in a pub called the Peacock, when he claimed that Alan Chard arranged for the purchase of two guns.

It is clear that this version of event was loosely based on a meeting which really did take place. The other characters in the meeting are identifiable. Two of them are said by Jimmy Trusty to have provided the guns for Alan Chard to sell. But the police never interviewed them.

Police arrested a man called George Quinlan and seized a large quantity of money from his safe. Quinlan was subsequently tried separately and acquitted by a jury which did not believe the word of the informers. But his arrest uncovered the only piece of potential corroboration for the informers’ allegations about Alan Chard – an envelope full of money with ‘Allen’ written on the outside. This was said to have been found in Mr Quinlan’s safe.

But the handwriting on the envelope was not Mr Quinlan’s nor Mr Chard’s; and the name was wrongly spelled, despite the fact that the two men had known each other for years. The judge at Alan Chard’s trial refused to allow the prosecution to use the envelope as evidence.

Last August Mr Leon Brittan, who was then Minister of State at the Home Office, agreed to a request from Stephen Ross MP to look at the facts of the Chard case. Mr Brittan asked Scotland Yard to conduct a full inquiry. Last December, the Yard produced a 115-page report for Mr Brittan. But Peter Wilding says that he was never interviewed by the police who conducted that inquiry, and never given the chance to admit that he lied.

Jim Colla’s detective work and Peter Wilding’s statement provide a wealth of detail on the way in which Alan Chard was wrongly convicted, but grey areas remain. In particular, it is not clear just why Alan Chard was chosen by the informer.

He had met Philip Trusty, one of the leading flgures in the team of robbers, in prison. He had been to a party which was probably attended by two of the informers, Jimmy Trusty and Billy Williams, so he was vaguely known to them.

When he was arrested, Alan Chard had only recently been released from prison. The police and the informers knew that he had served 11 years for robbery and possession of gelignite. Mr Chard says that he was told by one detective that he was ‘tailor-made’ to take the blame.

It has been a feature of ‘supergrass’ cases that each informer tries to improve his credibility with the jury by minimising his own role in crimes. This presents the practical problem of explaining who was responsible if they were not. It seems likely that Alan Chard entered the case in this way.

It may be that the police were unaware of the extent of the fabrication by the informers and that, like the jury at Chard’s trial, they were taken in.

It was announced at the end of last year, in the wake of a series of unsuccessful ‘supergrass’ prosecutions, that the Director of Public Prosecutions was reviewing the use of informers. But a spokesman for the DPP’s office said last week that cases would still be brought on their uncorroborated evidence. “There is no hard and fast rule about it,” a spokesman said.

 

The sentences that tell the story:

Alan Chard was convicted on three charges of conspiring to rob banks at the Old Bailey on November 21, 1975. He was sentenced to 15 years’ imprisonment on each count. This was reduced to 12 on appeal.

At the same trial, Philip Trusty was sentenced to life imprisonment with concurrent sentences of 20 years and 15 years after being found guilty of attempted murder, robbery, and conspiracy to rob. Cornelius Hyde was sentenced to 18 years for robbery. Nicholas Smith was sentenced to 10 years for robbery and conspiracy to rob. Rudolph Cook was sentenced to eight years for conspiracy to rob. Stanley McCarthy was sentenced to 12 years for robbery. Roger Jenkins was sentenced to 18 months, suspended for two years, for conspiring to rob. John Williams was given a 12-month suspended sentence for receiving £100.

The three men who turned Queen’s Evidence were tried separately.

Billy Williams admitted three counts of armed robbery and asked for 36 other offences to be taken into consideration. He was sentenced to five years at the Old Bailey on December 9 1974, but released after 14 months under the royal prerogative.

Jimmy Trusty admitted one charge of robbery and was sentenced at the Old Bailey to two and a half years in prison on April 10, 1975. He was released on parole a year later.

Peter Wilding admitted taking part in two conspiracies to rob. He was given a 12-month sus-pended sentence at the Old Bailey on May 6, 1975.