IRA suspect denounces trial judge

The Guardian, 21 June 1980

The defendant in the IRA conspiracy trial at the Old Bailey yesterday interrupted the judge’s summing-up and accused him of being immoral, twisted, and prejudiced.

Brian Keenan, aged 38, who has denied four charges of conspiring to cause explosions and possessing firearms, interrupted Mr Justice Kenneth Jones as he reminded the jury of Mr Keenan’s statement from dock earlier in the trial.

The judge said that the jury might think the statement had less cogency or value than if it been made under oath from the witness box.

Police had been unable to confirm Mr Keenan’s claim that officers searched the house where he was staying in England, and this was the one point in his statement which could be checked

Concluding his summary of Mr Keenan’s statement, the judge said: “Well, that is he says.” From the dock, Mr Keenan said: “That’s how you gave it. Very, very clever presentation.”

Minutes later, the judge queried the defence’s failure to call the owner of the house to corroborate Mr Keenan’s claim that it had been raided.

“Because she can’t prove it, that’s why,” said Mr Keenan. The judge said he would not remind him again to be quiet. “You are immoral, twisted and prejudiced.” said Mr Keenan.

The jury is expected to retire today.