‘Unusual heavy weapon broke Blair Peach’s skull’

The Guardian, 19 May 1980

A weighted rubber cosh or a pipe filled with lead shot could have been the weapon which fractured the skull of London teacher Blair Peach, the inquest jury was told yesterday.

Professor Arthur Mant, the pathologist called in by the Peach family said that the injury was severe and could not have been caused by a relatively light police truncheon.

During the day, two constables with the Special Patrol Group admitted that they had struck people with their truncheons during the demonstration against the National Front in Southall last April. But they – and seven of their colleagues who were in the street where Mr Peach was struck – said that they did not see anyone being hit at that time.

Only one demonstrator, Amanda Leon, has been called to give evidence that Mr Peach was struck by a policeman with a truncheon-like stick. But yesterday the coroner, Dr John Burton, referred to a man – not named on the witness list – who gave a “graphic description” of how Mr Peach was killed.

The unexplained reference came during the questioning of SPG constable Edward Page. He was describing how he had helped to arrest a man in Beechcroft Avenue, only a few feet from where Mr Peach slumped to the ground. Constable Page said that he ran down the street with the specific intention of arresting a man who had thrown a stone at an officer’s legs. At the end of Beechcroft Avenue, he caught up with the man who was struggling with Inspector Douglas Hopkins, the head of SPG unit No 3. “I helped to arrest him and put him in the carrier which had drawn up across the pavement,” he said.

Dr Burton intervened, saying that that was the man who looked under his arm during the struggle and gave the graphic description of how Mr Peach received his injury. Constable Page said that it was unlikely that the man could see anything as his own line of vision was obstructed by his shield, which was dirty and difficult to see through. Constable Page said that he did not use his truncheon, nor did he see any prisoner or fleeing demonstrator being hit.

Inspector Hopkins. in his evidence earlier, said that the man he had got hold of was struggling so much that he had to jab him in the stomach with his truncheon.

Professor Mant, of Guy’s Hospital, London, said that Mr Peach died from an extradural haemorrhage after a fracture of the skull caused by a single heavy blow to the side of the head. He had been shown all the weapons and instruments found on the streets of Southall and later in SPG lockers but, he said, he did not think any of the ones he saw could have been responsible for the injury.

This was because of an unusual feature of the injury: despite the “severe crushing” of Mr Peach’s skull, there was no damage to the scalp, said Professor Mant. This suggested that the weapon used was malleable and did not have a sharp edge – unlike a police truncheon or the other weapons he had been shown.

Mr Stephen Sedley, counsel for the Peach family, showed Professor Mant a blackjack which had been bought in the United States. The professor flexed it in his hands. “This would be capable of producing the injury,” he said.

Another unusual feature of Mr Peach’s death was that he had suffered no other injury not even minor scratches. Professor Mant said that this suggested that Mr Peach had collapsed to the ground gently after being hit. He might have been sitting at the time, but he could not have been running.

Constable John Lane, now with the Diplomatic Protection Group, described two incidents where he had used his truncheon. “A man tried to kick me and I whacked him on the leg so he soon gave that up.” On another occasion, he said: ” I think there was a man who tried to kick Charlie Collins (an SPG officer). I banged him on the leg, and that deterred him.”

Several of the officers said yesterday that Southall was the worst demonstration they had had to police. Constable James Harvey said that when they came under attack from the demonstrators “it was the biggest barrage (of missiles) I have seen in my 20 years’ service. The sky was alive with missiles.”