Two witnesses yesterday told the inquest on Blair Peach that they saw him being struck over the head with a police truncheon during last April’s disturbances in Southall although they differed about details of where he was at the time.
Mr Parminder Singh Atwal, a car worker, told the Hammersmith coroners court that he saw Mr Peach standing in the road before apparently being pushed by one policeman and hit over the head by another. But Mr Atwal’s sister, Mrs Dayinda Sanghera, said Mr Peach had been sitting on pavement when a passing police officer hit him over the head. Mr Peach died later that night of a fractured skull.
Mr Atwal said he had been standing with his family in his front garden at Orchard Avenue watching the melee of policemen and demonstrators at the far end of Beechcroft Avenue. He had noticed Mr Peach standing on his own at the near end of the avenue. A few minutes later two police vans had turned off the Broadway and sped down Beechcroft Avenue after some demonstrators.
Policemen had got out about half way down the road. “They tried to make arrests and started beating people and pushing them with their shields,” said Mr Atwal. Some of the demonstrators had turned and run towards his house. He added: “The front door was open, and some people ran through the house to the back garden. Some ran through the side alley.”
Looking back towards the avenue, he had seen Mr Peach still standing in roughly the same place. Mr Atwal said: “There were two police officers – one with a shield and one without, I think. I think Blair Peach was pushed to the ground by the one with the shield. He was about to fall down and the other officer came up with his truncheon and while he was bending, he hit him over the head like this.” Mr Atwal bent double in the witness box to demonstrate. “Everything happened so quickly.”
One of his friends, standing near by, had been hit, and he had turned to look at him. A minute or more had passed before he had seen Mr Peach again. By then most of the crowd had left the avenue. Mr. Atwal said: “He was the only one left on the road. I looked at him, and he was sort of trying to get to the footpath. He was well into the kerb. He walked from there to the corner of Orchard Avenue and Beechcroft Avenue. He couldn’t walk properly and he sat by the wall.
“Soon after there were two or three police officers coming along Orchard Avenue. As they passed by Blair Peach they were saying: ‘Come on. Move.’ I was surprised to see their behaviour. This man was badly injured. I was thinking they might help him, instead they told him to move on. He was unable to move on. He was so scared that they might hit him again. He was putting his hands up to his head.”
As the policeman passed, Mr Peach had got up, spotted Mr Atwal and staggered across the road towards him. Mr Atwal added: “He was about to collapse, so then I walked to him and held him by the shoulders and brought him into the front garden. He was trembling all the time. I asked him if he was all right and he didn’t say a word.” He had given him a glass of water, but Mr Peach had been unable to grip it.
The coroner, Dr John Burton, asked Mr Atwal if he had seen what the policeman had used to strike Mr Peach. “It was a thin black truncheon,” he replied, “the sort that I know the police carry with them.”
Cross examined by Mr Brian Watling, for the Metropolitan Police Commissioner, Mr Atwal said four plain-clothes policemen came to his house at about 11 p.m. on the night of the riot. He had gone to work so the policemen questioned his mother and father about what had happened. Questioned by Mr Stephen Sedley for the Peach family, he said that when the truncheon fell it was ‘a single, heavy blow.’
Mrs Sanghera told the inquest that Mr Peach was struck as he was sitting against the wall with his hands held up to his head. Her evidence to the court, it emerged, was different in several respects from the statement she had made to the police four days after the event. Her account of the attack was that Mr Peach was sitting with his back against the wall. “A policeman was standing there. He was hitting him on the head with a truncheon. I just saw him hit once.” Mr Peach’s hands were held up to his head.
Mr Philip Dyer, formerly attached to Willesden Green police station and who left the force in 1979, denied having boasted to a British tourist on a Greek island that he and another officer had killed Blair Peach and been told by their superiors to lie low while the inquiry was conducted.
The inquest resumes on Monday.
* Several policemen were running through a garden in Southall when one of them stopped and struck a 19-year-old girl on the head with his truncheon, it was alleged at the inquest yesterday.
Miss Maria Sullivan, a hospital records officer, said she had run into the garden to get away from police activity in Beechcroft Avenue. “They were hitting people at random,” she said.
She had been standing there with a friend when three or four people ran through and shouted: “Run, the police are coming.” Her friend and the others jumped into other gardens, but she had thought it would be safer to stay where she was and let the police pass.
The second or third policeman who went through had struck her on the head with his truncheon. The policeman had run on without saying a word. “I put my hand to my head and when I took it away it was covered in blood. Another policeman came and just pushed me down and said: ‘Wait there. We will be back for you later.’ I was screaming and crying,” she added.
She said she had attended an identity parade of policemen but had picked out the wrong man because she was confused.