Blair Peach “had an unusually thin skull”

The Guardian, 10 May 1980

Blair Peach had an unusually thin skull which could have been crushed by a blow from a broad smooth instrument like a police radio, a pathologist yesterday told the inquest into his death.

The jury at the Hammersmith coroners court spent the morning examining skulls, including part of that of the dead teacher, and considering a mass of forensic evidence in an effort to clear away the confusion about his injuries.

The coroner, Dr John Burton, pointed to three odd features of Mr Peach’s death: his skull had been crushed, yet his scalp had not been cut at all; he seemed to have fallen to the ground without receiving the slightest scratch or bruise; and he had found his way to a nearby house when he should have been unconscious.

Dr Burton said that he could not accept either of the ‘extreme theories’ that had been put to him. “There is the police murder theory, that some policeman had a blackjack with him, which he is obviously unable to produce when there are people watching him. He eventually sees his opportunity, produces it and hits Blair Peach with one blow. This must be the only blow that he strikes since no other person has an injury like the injury that Blair Peach has.

“The other extreme, which I must say I think is equallly unacceptable, is some political fanatic who says ‘Here is the perfect demonstration to have a martyr, such as at Red Lion Square.’ He coshes Blair Peach while he is running. Whichever theory one looks at has drawbacks.”

Professor David Bowen, professor of forensic medicine at Charing Cross Hospital, said that he had examined Mr Peach’s body at the coroner’s request on April 24, the day after he died during demonstrations at Southall. “I discovered the skull to be distinctly thinner than I would expect in a man of this age,” he said. It was 3/16 of an inch thick at its thickest point, compared to the normal 1/4. At its thinnest point, over the vessels and arteries which had been ruptured, it was only a millimetre thick.

Cross-examined by Mr Stephen Sedley, counsel for the Peach family, Professor Bowen said: “I’m not suggesting that the fracture would not occur if the skull was very thick. It’s fair to say that this fracture would not be so extensive if the skull was thicker. That is all one can say.”

But, having seen how thin the skull was, Professor Bowen added, he was able to imagine how any weighty, broad, smooth instrument could have done the damage to the skull without breaking the outer skin. He had examined all the instruments and weapons found in the streets of Southall, and later in SPG lockers. He particularly noticed the SPG radio, which was seven inches by three, with a leather casing. He said: “Of all the things I have seen, this to me was the most likely instrument to caused the fatal injury.”

He believed that the blow that struck Mr Peach would have stunned him but he would not necessarily have collapsed on to the ground, adding that Mr Peach would not necessarily have become unconscious immediately. “He could have walked a certain distance. It’s like a person who has been stabbed in the heart,” he said. The jury examined five skull specimens which Professor Bowen had brought from a pathological museum alongside pieces of Mr Peach’s skull.

Later, they were played a tape recording of the radio activity on the special channel reserved for inspectors on the day of the Southall demonstrations. On Monday, when the inquest resumes, they are to hear a tape of the regular channel used at Southall by ordinary Metropolitan policemen. They have been unable to hear what was said on the Special Patrol Group channel because it was not recorded.